Under HMRC’s new points-based penalty system for Making Tax Digital (MTD), taxpayers who miss a submission deadline face a penalty point assessment rather than a fine. Only when an individual has four points does the taxpayer face tax penalties. Therefore, for taxpayers who use MTD Annual or Quarterly, Income Tax Self-Assessment (ITSA) filers, making tax digital penalties only come into play when an individual has four points. At that point, HMRC imposes a financial penalty. Every subsequent missed deadline while remaining at the four-point threshold incurs an additional financial penalty. Separate financial charges apply to late tax payments based on percentages of the unpaid amount and daily interest, rather than mtd penalty points.
How HMRC’s Penalty Points System Operates
HMRC introduced the points-based regime, which replaced automatic initial fines on day one of a missed Self Assessment deadline as a result of trying to penalize persistent non-compliance as opposed to the occasional minor oversight.
Late Payment Penalties and Interest Charges
Unlike late filing, late tax payments do not accrue mtd penalty points. Instead, HMRC charges percentage-based penalties and daily late payment interest on outstanding balances.
Percentage Penalty Tiers
Late payment penalties accrue in stages based on how quickly the balance is settled or a payment plan is agreed:
- Initial grace period: No penalty charged if paid in full or if a Time to Pay arrangement is requested within this window.
- Secondary window: A first percentage penalty applies to the tax unpaid at the initial threshold date. (For the first year under new MTD rules, HMRC extends this grace window, meaning no late payment penalty applies during this extended initial period).
- Extended overdue period: A second percentage penalty applies to the balance unpaid at the secondary threshold date, plus an annual percentage rate charged daily on the outstanding balance until paid in full.
MTD Software Compliance and Record-Keeping
Filing updates with unauthorized software can result in its own making tax digital penalties. HMRC requires taxpayers to keep digital records of all their income and expenditure and report it by using MTD-compatible, or bridging, software.
Key Record-Keeping Requirements
In order to prevent submission errors or inaccuracies:
- Digital links: The information has to travel digitally by connecting the software sets to eliminate the necessity of manual copying-pasting procedures.
- Transaction details: Every record has to contain the invoice date, amount, and type of income or expenditure.
Failure to report tax information correctly by using compliant software or keeping the data links between the programs would result in a taxpayer liable to a penalty charge of non-compliance established by HMRC on a flat-rate basis.
Speak to our MTD for sole traders
Our ACCA regulated team in Mayfair can review your situation and make sure you get it right first time.
Find out more Free consultationAppealing MTD Penalty Points and Fines
You can appeal mtd penalty points or late payment penalties if you have a reasonable excuse for missing the deadline. An appeal must be submitted within the statutory notification window following HMRC’s notice. HMRC does not accept forgetfulness, inaccessibility of software, or insufficient funds to pay taxes as reasonable excuses. However, if you cannot afford to pay your tax liability, you should contact HMRC and request a Time to Pay arrangement to avoid additional penalties.
How Synergy Tax Accountants Can Help
Adapting to Making Tax Digital requirements requires establishing reliable digital record-keeping practices and tracking multiple filing deadlines throughout the tax year. Synergy Tax Accountants assists sole traders, limited company directors, and property landlords across the UK in setting up MTD-compliant software, managing quarterly updates, and submitting final tax declarations accurate and on time. Our team reviews your income sources to confirm exact MTD start dates, sets up digital links across your accounting records, and coordinates directly with HMRC if you need to set up payment arrangements or appeal making tax digital penalties. To discuss your Making Tax Digital setup or ensure your business is fully compliant ahead of upcoming deadlines, contact Synergy Tax Accountants to arrange an initial consultation.
Chartered certified accountants regulated by ACCA, based in Mayfair, London and Southend-on-Sea. This guide is general information, not personal advice. Contact us for advice on your situation.




